Is San Jose really as safe as the statistics suggest, or are repeat offenders raising concerns for local residents and homebuyers?
San Jose has earned a reputation as one of America’s safest major cities. In fact, a national study ranked it number one among the 50 largest cities in the country.
And the crime numbers have been moving in the right direction. Violent crime and property crime both declined in 2025.
But there’s another side to this story.
We’ve seen businesses repeatedly targeted by the same offenders, and a San Jose police sergeant was shot during a confrontation with an armed robbery suspect who had previously been released on parole.
So how can San Jose rank as America’s safest big city while these kinds of incidents continue happening?
It’s a question worth examining, especially if you’re thinking about buying a home here. One of the first questions I hear from buyers is whether a particular neighborhood is safe. I’ve also seen how a previous break-in can make a home harder to sell because some buyers simply can’t get past that history.
Let’s look at what the numbers actually tell us, what’s happening with repeat offenders, and what this means for people living in or considering a move to San Jose.
Watch the original video:
Why San Jose Was Named America’s Safest Big City
According to SmartAsset’s 2025 study, San Jose ranked first among the 50 largest cities in America.
The study compared several indicators, including:
- Violent crime
- Property crime
- Vehicular deaths
- Drug overdose deaths
- Excessive drinking
San Jose performed well across all five categories, placing among the top 10 cities for every safety measure.
That is an encouraging result, especially considering the size of the city and its population.
However, there’s something important to understand about the ranking. The crime figures in the study came from FBI data for 2023, while the other three health and safety indicators were measured at the county level.
So while the ranking is useful for comparing major cities, it isn’t a real-time measurement of every neighborhood or individual street.
You can read the full SmartAsset 2025 Safest Cities study to see how the rankings were calculated.
San Jose Crime Statistics Are Moving in the Right Direction
There is more good news when we look at the city’s actual crime trends.
According to FBI Uniform Crime Reporting figures reported in January 2026, San Jose experienced the following changes in 2025 compared with 2024:
- Violent crime decreased by 15%.
- Property crime decreased by 7%.
These are meaningful improvements.
The city’s downward trend is encouraging, and it shows that the overall public safety picture isn’t necessarily getting worse.
But citywide crime statistics don’t tell us everything.
A decline in the overall number of reported crimes doesn’t mean every neighborhood experiences the same improvement. And it doesn’t necessarily reflect the experiences of people who have been directly affected by crime.
That’s where the issue of repeat offenders becomes important.
Why Repeat Offenders Are a Serious Concern
Here’s something about crime that might surprise you.
A relatively small number of people can account for a disproportionately large share of offenses.
A famous Philadelphia birth-cohort study followed boys born in 1945 through their juvenile years. Researchers found that approximately 6% of the cohort accounted for 52% of its recorded delinquent offenses.
That study doesn’t establish the same pattern in San Jose today, but it illustrates why repeat offending has received so much attention.
And San Jose has reported similar concerns.
City officials have previously cited San Jose Police Department figures showing that, during a 14-month period, 30 individuals were arrested at least 10 times. One person was arrested 19 times.
You can see why police officials became frustrated with what they described as a revolving door in the criminal justice system.
A San Jose Burglar Arrested Again and Again
One example involved Jonny Miles, a prolific commercial burglary suspect.
According to the San Jose Police Department, Miles had previously been charged with 15 commercial burglaries committed in San Jose in 2020. He served approximately two years in Santa Clara County Main Jail before being released in early 2023.
He was subsequently charged with 21 more commercial burglaries in San Jose in 2023 and was released again from jail in May 2026.
The situation didn’t end there.
In July 2026, police arrested him in connection with three additional commercial burglaries. According to SJPD, he was in the process of committing a fourth burglary when officers located him.
Then came two more incidents.
On August 17, 2026, police say Miles threw a brick through the front door of a business on Senter Road, causing thousands of dollars in damage.
The following day, investigators linked him to an attempted burglary on East Capitol Expressway, where police say he threw a rock at another business’s door and kicked it down.
Miles was arrested again on August 20 and was listed as in custody in the department’s August 31 update.
Imagine being one of those business owners. You’re trying to run your business, and suddenly you’re dealing with another damaged entrance and thousands of dollars in repairs.
One salon owner described the feeling as helpless.
It’s difficult to understand that frustration unless you’ve experienced something like it yourself.
Read the San Jose Police Department’s official report on the burglary suspect.
The Shooting of Sergeant Matt Walsh
A much more serious incident happened on August 25, 2026.
San Jose police were pursuing Anthony Chavez, a suspect wanted in connection with two armed robberies.
During the pursuit, Chavez entered an occupied family’s home and hid in a bathroom.
Sergeant Matt Walsh, a 19-year veteran of the San Jose Police Department, was the first officer through the bathroom door.
Chavez shot him twice.
Thankfully, Sergeant Walsh survived.
The suspect was killed during the confrontation, and the family inside the home was not injured.
But the incident raised serious questions about how Chavez ended up back on the streets.
According to Police Chief Paul Joseph, Chavez had committed four armed robberies in 2011 and was sentenced to 23 years in prison in 2016. He was later resentenced and released on parole in October 2025.
Within six months, he was arrested again on new charges while on parole. The police chief said prosecutors objected when a judge subsequently released him.
Chavez also failed to report for GPS monitoring and missed his next court date.
The police chief publicly said Chavez should have remained in custody.
I don’t know everything the judge considered when making that decision. But when a person with a serious criminal history is released and subsequently fails to comply with release conditions, it’s reasonable to ask whether the system is working as intended.
Read the KTVU report on the incident and the suspect’s criminal history.
What California’s Criminal Justice Laws Have to Do With It
Whenever repeat offenders become a public concern, two California propositions often come up: Proposition 47 and Proposition 36.
But understanding what these laws actually changed is important.
Proposition 47: The 2014 Criminal Justice Reform
In 2014, California voters approved Proposition 47.
The measure reduced penalties for certain low-level drug possession and theft offenses.
For example, certain theft offenses involving property valued at $950 or less became misdemeanors instead of felonies, subject to specific exceptions.
The goal was to reduce prison sentences for lower-level offenses and redirect some of the resulting savings toward mental health services, drug treatment, schools, and victim services.
Supporters viewed it as a necessary criminal justice reform.
Critics argued that the changes weakened consequences for certain property and drug offenses.
You can review the official Proposition 47 summary.
Proposition 36: Voters Wanted a Change
Ten years later, California voters approved Proposition 36 in November 2024.
Nearly 70% supported the measure, with the final statewide result at 68.4%.
Proposition 36 allows felony charges for certain repeat theft and drug offenses, including some offenses involving thefts under $950 when the required prior convictions exist.
It also created a treatment-mandated felony pathway for certain drug possession cases. Eligible defendants who complete the required treatment can have their charges dismissed.
The measure took effect on December 18, 2024.
On paper, that sounds like a reasonable balance between accountability and rehabilitation.
But there’s a problem: treatment programs need to be available for the system to work.
In a September 2026 investigation, CalMatters reported on the shortage of treatment programs across California.
Santa Clara County Superior Court Judge Stephen Manley, who handles drug and mental health cases, described the situation as a shortage of available treatment in the county.
That means even when someone is eligible for treatment, getting access to a program can be a challenge.
Read the CalMatters investigation into Proposition 36 and treatment availability.
Did California’s Bail Rules Change How Judges Make Release Decisions?
There’s another important development worth understanding.
In 2021, the California Supreme Court issued a decision in In re Humphrey.
The ruling addressed whether someone could be held in jail before trial simply because they couldn’t afford bail.
The court ruled that judges must consider a person’s ability to pay when setting money bail. A person cannot be detained solely because they lack the financial resources to pay an unaffordable bail amount.
However, this does not mean judges must release everyone.
Courts can still order pretrial detention when the legal requirements are met, including circumstances where clear and convincing evidence establishes that no less restrictive condition can reasonably protect public or victim safety.
That’s an important distinction.
And the decision is not a blanket explanation for every release involving a repeat offender. The parole and release issues in the cases discussed earlier involve separate legal decisions.
You can read the California Supreme Court’s In re Humphrey decision.
What the Crime Statistics Don’t Tell Us About Feeling Safe
Now let’s return to the question we started with.
Is San Jose actually safe?
The numbers provide one part of the answer, but residents’ experiences matter too.
Interestingly, the City of San Jose conducted a 2025 community survey to understand how safe residents actually feel.
The findings were revealing.
- 73% of respondents considered San Jose a very or somewhat safe place to live.
- 80% felt safe in their own neighborhood.
- 47% felt safe in downtown San Jose.
- Only 32% felt safe in downtown San Jose at night.
These figures show why it’s important to look beyond a single citywide ranking.
People can feel perfectly comfortable in their own neighborhoods while having a very different experience in another part of the city.
And that doesn’t necessarily contradict the overall crime statistics.
Both things can be true at the same time.
See the City of San Jose’s 2025 Community Opinion Survey.
What Does This Mean for People Buying a Home in San Jose?
For homebuyers, I think there’s an important lesson here.
Don’t rely entirely on a city’s reputation or a national safety ranking when deciding where to buy.
San Jose is a large city, and conditions can differ significantly between neighborhoods and even between nearby streets.
When evaluating a property, consider:
- Checking available crime information for the specific area.
- Visiting the neighborhood at different times of the day.
- Understanding the surrounding businesses, streets, and activity.
- Speaking with people who already live in the area.
- Reviewing available information from local law enforcement.
The San Jose Police Department provides crime statistics and mapping resources that residents can use to research reported crime activity.
You can also explore San Jose and surrounding neighborhoods to learn more about the different communities throughout the area.
A citywide ranking can be a good starting point, but it shouldn’t be the only factor in a major home purchase.
Who’s Holding the Door?
There’s one final question worth considering.
When we talk about repeat offenders, we often blame the criminal justice system as a whole. But responsibility is spread across several parts of that system.
Voters determine the laws. Prosecutors decide what charges to pursue. Judges make decisions about detention and release. Probation officers and other agencies help monitor people who are released under supervision.
Each has a role to play.
And local elections matter, too.
In the June 2026 Santa Clara County election, 33 local contests had no opposing candidate, including 28 Superior Court judge positions.
California Superior Court judges serve six-year terms and are elected by county voters, although vacancies are frequently filled through gubernatorial appointments before an election.
Yet how much attention do most of us pay to judicial elections?
We spend plenty of time discussing crime and public safety, but perhaps we should also pay closer attention to the people making decisions within the system.
Because somewhere along the way, accountability matters.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is San Jose really the safest big city in America?
San Jose ranked first among 50 major U.S. cities in SmartAsset’s 2025 safest-cities study. The ranking considered violent crime, property crime, vehicular deaths, drug overdose deaths, and excessive drinking.
Did crime decrease in San Jose in 2025?
Yes. Reported violent crime decreased by 15%, while property crime fell by 7% compared with 2024, according to FBI Uniform Crime Reporting figures reported in January 2026.
Does San Jose’s safety ranking mean every neighborhood is equally safe?
No. The ranking reflects citywide comparisons. Individual neighborhoods and streets can have different conditions, so buyers should research the specific area they’re considering.
What did California Proposition 47 change?
Approved in 2014, Proposition 47 reduced penalties for certain low-level theft and drug possession offenses, including specified theft offenses involving $950 or less.
What is Proposition 36?
Approved by California voters in 2024, Proposition 36 allows felony charges for certain repeat theft and drug offenses and creates a treatment-mandated felony option for eligible drug possession cases.
Did California’s 2021 bail ruling require judges to release repeat offenders?
No. The In re Humphrey decision addressed the use of unaffordable money bail. It does not require judges to release everyone, and courts can order pretrial detention when applicable legal requirements are satisfied.
Final Thoughts
So, is San Jose really America’s safest big city?
The numbers certainly make a strong case. Crime has declined, and San Jose continues to perform well compared with other major cities.
But the individual stories matter too.
For the business owner dealing with repeated break-ins, the family whose home became the scene of a police shooting, or the buyer worried about the neighborhood they’re considering, a national ranking doesn’t tell the whole story.
Ultimately, public safety isn’t just about having good statistics. It’s also about how safe people actually feel, whether the rules are being enforced, and whether the people responsible for public safety are being held accountable.
I’d be curious to hear what you think. Are California’s laws too lenient, are judges making the wrong decisions, or are we failing to enforce the rules already in place?
And if you’re considering buying or selling a home in San Jose, we’d be happy to help you understand the local market and the neighborhoods you’re considering.Kip and Tam | Barnard Group – San Jose
DRE# 01428934 | Compass
Website: https://kipandtam.com
Phone: (408) 515-8277


